본문 바로가기

특강·영상/창조·진화론

[[창조과학]] 공룡뼈화석에서 온전한 혈관조직과 세포발견

약 7억년전에 지구상에 살았다는 공룡의 화석에서 혈관조직과 연골조직그리고 세포들이 온전한 상태로 발견될 수 있을까? 2005년 3월호 사이언스( Schweitzer, M. H., J. L. Wittmeyer, J. R. Horner, J. K. Toporski. 2005. Soft-Tissue Vessels and Cellular Preservation in Tyrannosaurus rex. Science 307: 1952-1955. )에 실린 연구결과를 보면, 공룡화석에서 온전한 연골조직과 혈관조직 및 세포들이 발견되었으며, 이는 공룡이 약 7억년전에 존재하였다는 진화론자의 주장이 거짓임을 과학적으로 입증된거와 마찬가지라 할 수 있다. 이러한 조직들이 7억년이나 지나면서 아래의 그림처럼 온전히 보전될 수는 없기 때문이다.  

 

반면에 창조론자들의 주장대로 지구의 나이는 6000년정도이며, 공룡이 번성했던 시기는 약 5000년전임을 감안할 때, 공룡화석에서 혈관조직 및 세포들이 온전히 발견될 수도 있음을 예상할 수 있을 것이다. 물론 5000년이나 지나면서도 혈관조직 및 세포들이 온전히 보관될 수 있다니, 놀랄 일이긴 하지만, 최소한 7억년전의 화석이라는 진화론자의 주장은 정말 설득력이 없는 것이다.

 

 

Tyrannosaurus Blood Vessels Found


In the 25 March issue of Science, a team led by Mary Schweitzer of North Carolina State University in Raleigh describes finding flexible and elastic blood vessels, and possibly intact cells, in the 68 million-year-old skeleton of a Tyrannosaurus rex.

A stretch? Dissolved T. rex bone yielded flexible, branching vessels (left), some of which contain cell-like structures (right).
CREDIT: M. H. Schweitzer

The skeleton was excavated in 2003 from the Hell Creek Formation of Montana by co-author Jack Horner's crew from the Museum of the Rockies in Bozeman, Montana. Back in the lab, Schweitzer and her technician demineralized the fragments by soaking them in a weak acid. As the fossil dissolved, transparent vessels were left behind. "It was totally shocking," Schweitzer says. Branching vessels also appeared in fragments from a hadrosaur and another Tyrannosaurus skeleton. Many of the vessels contain red and brown structures that resemble cells. And inside these are smaller objects similar in size to the nuclei of the blood cells in modern birds.

If the cells consist of original material, paleontologists might be able to extract new information about dinosaurs. For instance, they could use the same sort of protein antibody testing that helps biologists determine the evolutionary relationships of living organisms. "There's a reasonable chance that there may be intact proteins," says David Martill of the University of Portsmouth in the United Kingdom. Perhaps, he says, even DNA might be extracted.

Hendrik Poinar of McMaster University in Hamilton, ontario, cautions that looks can deceive: Nucleated protozoan cells have been found in 225-million-year-old amber, but geochemical tests revealed that the nuclei had been replaced with resin compounds. Even the resilience of the vessels may be deceptive. Flexible fossils of colonial marine organisms called graptolites have been recovered from 440-million-year-old rocks, but the original material--likely collagen--had not survived.

Schweitzer is seeking funding for sophisticated tests that would use techniques such as mass spectroscopy and high performance liquid chromatography to check for dino tissue. As for DNA, which is less abundant and more fragile than proteins, Poinar says it's theoretically possible that some may have survived, if conditions stayed just right (preferably dry and subzero) for all 68 million years. "Wouldn't it be cool?" he muses, but adds "the likelihood is probably next to none."